Ökologischer Fehlschlag: Palmölplantagen in Indonesien befeuern den Klimwandel

Eine der großen Ungereimtheiten in der IPCC-Sichtweise ist die Interpretation der Erwärmung der letzten 150 Jahre. In seinem letzten IPCC-Bericht erklärt der Weltklimarat kurzerhand die gesamte beobachtete Erwärmung sei anthropogen. Diese pauschale Attribution macht natürlich wenig Sinn, wenn im selben Bericht eine riesige Spanne der CO2-Klimasensitivität von 1,5-4,5°C Erwärmung pro CO2-Verdopplung genannt wird. Im Maximum-Fall (4,5°C) sind die 100% anthropogen sicher zu rechtfertigen, aber im Minimumfall (1,5°C) muss man eine gehörige Portion an natürlichem Wärmeschub dazugeben, um auf die gemessene Erwärmung zu kommen. Insofern widerspricht sich der IPCC-Bericht also selber. Das passiert, wenn viele Köche am Werke sind und dann letztendlich den Brei verderben.

Die American Chemical Society (ACS) gab am 25. Oktober 2017 eine Pressemitteilung heraus, in der der Beginn des Anthropozäns diskutiert wird. Dabei werden schließlich die 1950er Jahre genannt. Wieder ein Hinweis darauf, dass man bei der Attribution der Erwärmung im 19. Jahrhundert und in der ersten Hälfte des 20. Jahrhundert viel vorsichtiger  sein muss als es aktuell geschieht.

——————

Die European Geosciences Union (EGU) bemängelte am 25. Oktober 2017 in einer Pressemitteilung die fehlende Nachhaltigkeit der Palmöl-Produktion in Südostasien, die den Klimawandel eher befeuert anstatt ihn zu dämpfen. Hier hat die grüne Bewegung eindeutig versagt, hat unter dem ökologischen Deckmäntelchen große Flächen tropischen Regenwaldes abholzen lassen, was nun nicht nur ein lokales ökologisches Problem darstellt, sondern auch das globale Klima schädigt. Hier die Meldung der EGU:

Deforestation linked to palm oil production is making Indonesia warmer

In the past decades, large areas of forest in Sumatra, Indonesia have been replaced by cash crops like oil palm and rubber plantations. New research, published in the European Geosciences Union journal Biogeosciences, shows that these changes in land use increase temperatures in the region. The added warming could affect plants and animals and make parts of the country more vulnerable to wildfires.

Palm oil is the most widely used vegetable oil in the world, appearing in the ingredients’ list of many consumer goods, from chocolate to soap. Indonesia, the world’s largest producer of palm oil, has seen large swathes of rainforest cleared away and replaced by oil palm plantations at rates that exceed those of Brazil. On the island of Sumatra, which has had the highest loss of native rainforest in all of Indonesia, the changes in land use have meant a substantial loss of animal and plant diversity. However, the impact of these changes on the region’s temperatures had not been studied until now.

An international team of researchers, led by Clifton Sabajo and Alexander Knohl from the University of Göttingen in Germany, have published a new study showing that the expansion of oil palm and other cash crops in Sumatra has made the region warmer. “Land use change from forest to cash crops such as oil palm and rubber plantations does not only impact biodiversity and stored carbon, but also has a surface warming effect, adding to climate change,” says Knohl, a professor in bioclimatology.

The team studied differences in surface temperature for various types of land cover, such as forests, clear-cut land, and cash crops, in the Jambi province of Sumatra. They used satellite data collected between 2000 and 2015 by the NASA Landsat missions and the MODIS instrument, as well as data collected on the ground.

They found that clear-cut land, which is mainly used for agriculture, was up to 10 °C warmer than forests. “Clear-cut land is the phase between forest and other land cover types, such as small-holders [small-scale family farms] or commercial plantations,” says Sabajo, a PhD student and the lead author of the Biogeosciences study. “From field observations, we know that the landscape is so dynamic that there are continuous land use changes all the time, so clear-cut land is always present.”

Mature palm oil plantations were about 0.8 °C warmer than forests, while young palm oil plantations were 6 °C warmer. “Young palm oil plantations have fewer and smaller leaves and an open canopy, thus they transpire less water. Also, the soil receives more solar radiation and dries out faster,” explains Sabajo. Mature palm oil plantations, which are older than 5 years, have a closed canopy and larger and more abundant leaves, which results in a cooler ground compared to a young plantation.

Sabajo says surface temperatures in forests are lower than in palm oil plantations and clear-cut land mainly because of “evaporative cooling”, which is similar to the process that cools us down when we sweat. There’s more evaporation and transpiration of water from plants and the soil into the atmosphere in a forest than in clear-cut land or a young oil-palm plantation, meaning the ground is cooler for that type of land cover.

Overall, the average mid-morning surface temperature in the Jambi province increased by 1.05 °C between 2000 and 2015. Some of this warming is a result of climate change, but some is a direct consequence of the changes in land use. “We compared the average land-surface temperature increase in the province with a site that was covered by forest over the entire period and that can be considered as a control, unaffected by direct land-use change. The land-surface temperature of the forest sites (at 10:30am) only increased by 0.45 °C, suggesting that at least 0.6 °C of the 1.05 °C increase is due to land-use change,” says Knohl.

“The strong warming effect we show for the Jambi province may serve as an indication of future changes in land-surface temperature for other regions of Indonesia that will undergo land transformations towards oil palm plantations,” the scientists write in the study. The Indonesian government plans to substantially expand the country’s production of oil palm, as the demand for this product increases around the world.

What this additional increase in temperature means for the region is yet unclear, but Knohl notes that “land surface temperature is an important part of the microclimate, which shapes habitat conditions for plants and animals.” In the study, they write that the observed warming may affect ecosystems, reduce how much water is available in the region over the dry season, as well as make the area more vulnerable to wildfires.

“We think that current land-use developments in Indonesia need to carefully evaluate all aspects of environmental and socio-economic consequences. Land-surface temperature and microclimate should be considered,” says Knohl.

The research is part of a large German-funded project, the Collaborative Research Centre 990: Ecological and Socioeconomic Functions of Tropical Lowland Rainforest Transformation Systems (Sumatra, Indonesia).

Publication in journal ‘Biogeosciences‘: (https://www.biogeosciences.net/14/4619/2017)

Die Hannoversche Allgemeine Zeitung (HAZ) berichtete über die Studie:

Forscher: Abholzung trägt zum Klimawandel bei
Wenn Wald abgeholzt und durch Ölpalmen-Plantagen ersetzt wird, führt dies zu einer messbaren Erwärmung und trägt so zum Klimawandel bei. Das berichtet die Universität Göttingen nach Untersuchungen in Indonesien.

Weiterlesen in der HAZ.